For the fan in enemy territory

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Mets fans need to root against Maine and Beltran

This season has been full of surprises for the New York Mets. They have shown dominance at home and futile efforts on the road. They have had several injuries to key players, but these injuries have been considered a blessing to some.

They have taken advantage of injured players and their vacated roster spots. Most notably, John Maine, Oliver Perez and Carlos Beltran. They have done this, by inserting hungry players to take their place. Players like Angel Pagan, R. A. Dickey and Hisanori Takahashi.

Take Dickey and Takahashi for example. They have combined for a 7-2 record in 9 combined starts. Their era's are 3.20 and 3.80 respectively. Compared to Oliver Perez and John Maine, who are a combined 1-6. Both are also sporting an era over 6.00. Granted, Dickey and Takahashi have amassed this combined record in half of the combined starts, but still impressive nonetheless.

It is an estimated 8 starts for the Dickey/Takahashi duo and 16 for the Perez/Maine combination. Still, this has been a breathe of fresh air for not only the ball club, but their fan base as well. Another case in point would be Angel Pagan. In his time with the Mets, he has shown flashes of greatness, only to have that fire extinguished by injuries.

Now he seems as healthy as ever and also as productive as ever. In his time so far this season, he has made the most of his opportunity. Going into today's double header, he has a .294 batting average with 4 home runs, 4 triples, 25 rbi's and 11 stolen bases in 56 games. In other words, he is not just taking advantage of his chance, but also of the ball park he is playing in.

While Carlos Beltran has been ridiculed and critiqued for his poor decision to have surgery nearly a month and a half before spring training, Pagan has flourished. With all this good, warm sunshine on the roster, must come news of rain. Not the rain that forced a double header today. But rather an interesting tidbit of news on the rehab front for the club.

According to Mike Puma of the New York Post, Maine and Beltran are making progress. Maine is preparing to make a few starts in the minors with the AA Binghamton club. He begins his stint with the AA team on June 13th. Also, Beltran has been starting split squad games down in Port St. Lucie under the careful watch of Mets brass and trainers.

This is all good news for them, but not necessarily for the team. If the Mets are to continue their rise in the standings and preserve team unity, they need to keep these hungry players around as long as they can. Keep in mind the players that are being discussed in rehab assignments are part of the old regime.

Beltran has been under the continual microscope over the past few seasons due to his repeated comments about division rivals and rivalries. His stats when healthy, have been wonderful, but he is not the best club house presence. Some may even call him stale air as opposed to the fresh air of the youth that has been pumped into that locker room as of late.

Maine has been scrutinized over heart and passion after comments in spring training and poor outings so far in the season. He is considering a move to the bullpen upon his return, which shows he is thinking of the team's needs. Still, how effective will he be if he continues to show a lack of intensity, especially in that role.

Oliver Perez has been a constant distraction in the locker room and in the media. His open refusal to be demoted to the minors to work out his problems and unproductive outings, have left him ostracized by both the media and the fans. Perhaps even the players may have alienated him for his selfishness as well.

This was followed by a controversial decision by the Mets to place him on the disabled list. That move has been investigated by the MLB and has since been approved. The transaction, though, was done in odd timing. A supposed injury to a disgruntled, struggling and cancerous to the club house type of player, is a curious move indeed.

All of these players may be nice people, as written and reported countless times by the Mets and their media affiliates, but they are not helping the team with their controversy or their selfishness. The replacements, however, are helping the team in several ways. If these players are in fact riding a hot streak in their careers and the Mets are catching lightning in a bottle, than they must be given every opportunity to succeed.

By succeeding individually, the team will succeed collectively. That is the common goal. Team work, dedication and energy. These present players are exhibiting those qualities. The old regime has proven one thing. They can't stay healthy long enough to be successful enough to make a run to the World Series.

The nucleus of this team is not getting younger and their time and prime are dwindling down. Game by wasted game, season by wasted season. The Mets roster has been turned over more times than a hamburger in a frying pan these past few seasons. While the same few players that the franchise has been built around are stuck in mediocrity, the team as a whole has either come up short or come up lame.

If they are to contend, they need passion, heart and confidence. I have previously written about this in an article entitled "Five things the Mets need to seriously contend".

In it I wrote the following:

" The swagger I speak of is that of confidence, not so much arrogance, but a realization that you're good and can match up with anyone. They had that once, and they need to reacquire it, or else they will be doomed to mediocrity."

These players bring that energy and confidence to every start and every at bat. If the Mets and their fans want all of the players to bring that energy and that air of confidence, then the Mets need to hang on to players that invigorate others. These players not only do so, but they make the team stronger, deeper and more exciting. That is something that has been missing for a few years now.


  1. I do like Carlos Beltran and remember what he did the last time he was playing for a contract in 2004. That was the year he split between the Royals and Astros and combined to hit 38 HR and steal 42 bases. Mr. Beltran knows how to produce when he's close to the end of a contract. Hopefully, he can do the same for the Mets before his current contract expires at the end of the 2011 season.

    As for Maine, I like that he puts his team first, unlike Oliver Perez, but I do not think he can be a quality big league pitcher for extended periods of time. He has shown occasional brilliance, but can't make those period last for too long. Plus, he's been spending more time in the trainer's room than on the mound.

    I'd like Beltran to stay (even though I'm a fan of Angel Pagan) but John Maine can and should be replaced.

  2. Ed, first thank you for your comment, as always I am honored. Next, let me say I like Beltran and Maine. I wish them the best, but my only point was perhaps the Mets are being productive right now because of these replacements. If that's the case, let's not be in such a hurry to rush these other guys back. Personally, I wouldn't care if I never saw Ollie again. Maine might be different to me, if he can contribute. I would love to see Beltran back at 100%. Not so sure that will happen. At least this year anyway. Again, thanks for posting Ed.